Is there enough data to draw a conclusion?.Are conditions adequate and the right controls in place?.Are the experiments or interventions appropriate for addressing the research question?.What experiments or interventions were used?.When you assess the methods used in the study, you are looking to determine whether the research is technically sound. Some questions you might consider, depending on the type of study, include: Do the figures and tables support the findings?.Is the presentation appropriate for the type of data being presented?.Are the figure and table captions complete and accurate?.Are the figures and tables clear and readable? (Keep in mind thatĭepending on the submission system you’re working in, you might have toĬlick a link to view the high-resolution versions of the authors’.Do not just take the figures and tables at face value. Make sure the manuscript text supports the data shown in the figuresĪnd tables. Do the authors identify other literature on the topic and explain how the study relates to this previously published research?.Do the authors summarize the main research question and key findings?.The authors should explain why the study matters and put the research in context. Want to take notes about what each section includes and identify the
Here’s a section-by-section guide of things to look for. Take lots of notes as you go along to get a jump start on writing your report. Then read the whole thing from beginning to end.Look at the figures and tables carefully in conjunction with the results.Not do a good job summarizing the findings, you might need to read Of the overall context and approach (if the abstract and introduction do Read the abstract and introduction to get a sense.Here’s one way to read the manuscript that involves going a bit out of order: It’s generally a good idea to read start to finish, but this is You should expect to read through the manuscript at least Make sure you read the entire manuscript, including theįigures. What are the conclusions? What are the authors’ main findings and what evidence do they provide for these conclusions?.What is the context? How does the study relate to published literature on this topic?.What is the approach? What did the authors do to address their research question?.What is the study about? What is the main research question?.It might be helpful to ask yourself these questions: The first step when reading is to figure out what the authors are Of your specialized knowledge and technical expertise. That the editors may not be experts in the field. Publication criteria, read these before you start your review. Journal editors make their decisions based on the journal’s Help the journal editors make their decision.Determine whether the authors’ claims are supported.What should you focus on when you review a scientific manuscript? This guide walks you through the process of reading a paper and identifying key things to mention in your review.
0 kommentar(er)
